Katy’s metallic blue shirtdress and fringe earrings on American Idol

Carrie’s distressed jeans on American Idol

Ripped Dad Jeans by Levi's at Nordstrom, $98

Also available at: Amazon

Carrie’s floral embroidered tulle dress on American Idol

Floral Embroidered Tulle Midi-Dress by Mac Duggal at Saks Fifth Avenue, $598

Also available at: Anthropologie

CeCe Winans’ beige floral gown on American Idol

Floral Velvet Devoré Cape Gown by Rodarte at Saks Fifth Avenue, $2760

Also available at: Moda Operandi

Carrie’s metallic beaded top on American Idol

Taraji Top in Bronze by Cult Gaia, $1198

Carrie’s pink colorblock leggings on American Idol

Zone High-Waisted 7/8 Leggings by Fabletics, $64.95