Jay’s white waffle knit sweater on Only Murders in the Building

Mabel’s gold hoop earrings on OMITB

Thread Hoops, 2.5-Inch by Jennifer Fisher at Nordstrom, $200

Mabel’s plaid vest on OMITB

Tamara Plaid Cotton-Blend Vest by Veronica Beard at Saks Fifth Avenue, $179.20 (was $448)

Also available at: Revolve

Mabel’s white pinstripe coat on OMITB

The Charles Trench Coat by Favorite Daughter at Saks Fifth Avenue, $214 (was $428)

Also available at: Revolve

Mabel’s blue ribbed cardigan on OMITB

Guspa Cardigan by Ba&sh at Shopbop, $380

Also available at: Tuckernuck

Mabel’s yellow sweater on OMITB

Sayla Rib Crop Sweater by Vero Moda at Nordstrom, $29.25 (was $45)